“Bailout”: A Failure to Communicate … Accurately

Words matter. That’s especially true for public relations professionals in industries subject to regulatory oversight, such as investment banking, financial services and insurance.

The legislation that was originally introduced under the title “Troubled Asset Relief Program” and evolved into the “Emergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008” was more popularly referred to by the average citizen — and quite a few legislators — as the “Wall Street Bailout.”

According to Wikipedia, “bailout” is a term used to describe a situation in which “a bankrupt or nearly bankrupt entity, such as a corporation or a bank, is given a fresh injection of liquidity, in order to meet its short term obligations.” Please note: a “bailout” would not be available to a consumer swamped by debt. And that may be at the crux of the overwhelmingly adverse reaction of American citizens to the initial proposals for averting the financial crisis.

In an article entitled “Main Street's Rage at the Financial Crisis,” BusinessWeek quotes Carol Madura, a waitress in her 50s, on the topic: “I brought up my kids to work hard and save money. Now what? The rich are getting bailouts. … The government just keeps taking our money and giving it to people who don't deserve it. We should be worried about those who are really struggling.”

If you’re involved in financial services public relations, insurance PR or investment banking PR, I’m sure you’ll agree that “bailout” is an altogether inadequate way to describe a proposed solution to a complex economic problem that threatens the financial well-being of all Americans.

A Reputational Roller Coaster Ride for Accountants

The accounting industry has successfully redeemed its reputation from its rock-bottom low in 2002, according to Gallup’s most recent Business & Industry Sector Ratings. But even now, complacency represents a serious threat … witness the effect of the subprime mortgage scandal on Bear Stearns. While the reputation of its management may have been besmirched, the credibility of its independent auditor, Deloitte & Touche, was not … largely because its statements, in an audit released last year, warned investors of the potential problem, according to WebCPA, citing a BusinessWeek story on the topic.

It’s my view that every accounting firm PR program should have a strong component dedicated to highlighting ethical standards. After all, do any of us truly believe — to the extent that we did seven years ago — that accountants provide a rock-solid guarantee of the honesty and accuracy of the financial statements that they audit? Enron was a watershed in this respect, and public relations must take this into account.